Recency bias is the tendency to treat your most recent experience as a better guide to the future than long-run history, and in investing it shows up as performance chasing: buying whatever fund, sector, or asset did best last year and dumping whatever did worst. The data says this usually backfires. A Morningstar study of 539 funds that ranked in the top half of their category found that only 52% held that ranking again the following year, barely better than a coin flip. Last year's winner tells you almost nothing reliable about next year's.
Why Does Your Brain Weight Recent Performance So Heavily?
Because recent, vivid information is easier to recall than older, duller information, and your brain mistakes "easy to recall" for "likely to repeat." A fund that doubled last year is a clear, memorable story. The twenty years of data showing most funds eventually revert toward average returns is a spreadsheet. Your brain reaches for the story every time, which is exactly how recency bias differs from a related bias: where anchoring bias fixates on a single past price point, recency bias fixates on a recent trend and extrapolates it forward, treating a temporary run as if it were the new normal.
What Does the Research Actually Say About Chasing Last Year's Winners?
It says chasing tends to cost you, not help you. Beyond the Morningstar coin-flip finding, a study by Cornell and Hsu found that a portfolio built from the top 10% of U.S. equity funds over the prior three years went on to trail average-performing funds by more than 100 basis points per year over the following three years. The worst-ranked funds, the ones recency bias tells you to avoid, actually did better by comparison: they underperformed their benchmark by just 0.11% a year, versus a 2.39% annual shortfall for the "winners." In a 2019 Cerulli survey of more than 300 financial advisers conducted for Charles Schwab, 35% named recency bias as the single most damaging bias they see in clients, ahead of loss aversion at 26%, which tells you this isn't a fringe problem. It's the single bias advisers run into most.
There is one documented exception worth being honest about: a 2025 AJ Bell analysis found that buying each year's best-performing market sector returned more over a 10-year stretch than buying the prior year's worst-performing sector. But the same analysis found a plain global index tracker beat every version of that strategy over the same 10 years, and the researchers were explicit that the result wasn't a reliable one-way strategy. The exception doesn't undo the broader pattern. It just shows that even the data supporting performance chasing ends up favoring the boring, diversified option anyway.
What Does Chasing Winners Actually Cost You Over Time?
Run the Cornell and Hsu gap forward and the cost compounds the same way returns do. Say you invest $10,000 and earn a market-average 8% annually for 20 years: you'd end up with about $46,610. Now say instead you spend those 20 years rotating into the prior year's top-decile fund, carrying that documented roughly 1-percentage-point annual drag, for a 7% average return instead: you'd end up with about $38,697. That's a difference of nearly $7,913, on a single $10,000 investment, generated entirely by one habit: buying what already went up instead of staying invested. This is an illustration of a real, documented average gap, not a guarantee, since any individual year could go either way. But the direction of the gap, and the size of it once it compounds, is the part recency bias hides from you in the moment.
How Do You Actually Catch Recency Bias Before It Costs You?
- Ask how long the "trend" has actually run. A fund, sector, or asset that's outperformed for 12 months has a much weaker claim on your attention than one with a 10-year record, even though the 12-month version is the one you're more likely to have seen highlighted somewhere.
- Check what happened the last time this exact pattern showed up. Research shows that reviewing more information before making a decision measurably reduces recency bias; a study of individual investor tax-loss sales found that investors who reviewed more history before selling were less swayed by short-term results.
- Separate "this did well" from "this will keep doing well." Those are two different claims, and recency bias works by quietly merging them into one. Writing down the actual, separate reasoning for each before you act makes the merge harder to pull off on yourself.
- Default to staying invested in a diversified position rather than rotating. Every study above, including the one exception, ultimately favored a boring, broadly diversified holding over actively chasing whatever just won.
None of this requires predicting which fund or sector wins next year, which is the entire point. It requires noticing when "this just did well" is doing the work that "this will keep doing well" should be doing instead. Recency bias shares a lot of DNA with anchoring bias, where a fixed reference point distorts your decisions in a different direction, and with the disposition effect, where the same short-term thinking shows up on the selling side. If the fix you're looking for is a mechanical one that doesn't depend on catching yourself in the moment, our breakdown of dollar-cost averaging vs. lump-sum investing covers a strategy built specifically to remove this kind of timing decision from the equation entirely.
—
Spicy Investing
