What Happens If You Miss Your RMD Deadline? The 25% Penalty, Explained

Missing your required minimum distribution deadline triggers an excise tax of 25% of the amount you should have withdrawn and didn't, not the 50% penalty that applied before 2023. That rate drops further, to 10%, if you correct the shortfall within a two-year window. On a $20,000 missed RMD, that's the difference between a $5,000 tax and a $2,000 one, and the gap only closes if you act fast and file the right form. The deadline itself is December 31 for almost everyone already taking RMDs, no extensions, no grace period on the date itself.

What Is the Actual Penalty for Missing an RMD?

The penalty is a 25% excise tax under Internal Revenue Code Section 4974, charged on the shortfall, meaning the difference between what you were required to withdraw and what you actually withdrew by the deadline, not on your entire account balance. Before SECURE 2.0 Act changes took effect for tax years beginning after December 29, 2022, that rate was 50%, enough to wipe out half of whatever you forgot to take. The 25% rate is real relief, but it's still a hard number to absorb on a distribution you may have simply forgotten, lost track of after changing custodians, or miscalculated.

How Does the Penalty Drop to 10%?

If you correct the missed distribution within what the IRS calls the correction window, generally by the end of the second tax year after the year the RMD was due, the excise tax rate falls from 25% to 10% on that shortfall. "Correcting" means actually withdrawing the amount you missed, not just promising to, and then reporting it properly. This reduced rate isn't automatic forgiveness, it's a lower fixed rate you qualify for by fixing the mistake quickly, which is exactly why catching a missed RMD in the same year or the next one matters so much more than catching it five years later.

How Do You Actually Fix a Missed RMD?

  • Take the missed distribution immediately. Contact your custodian and withdraw the full shortfall as soon as you discover it. The clock on the correction window doesn't pause while you figure out the paperwork.
  • File IRS Form 5329 for each tax year a shortfall occurred. This is the form that reports the excise tax, and it's also where you indicate the lower 10% rate if you corrected within the window.
  • Attach a letter requesting a waiver in Part IX of Form 5329 if you have reasonable cause, such as a serious illness, a custodian error, or incorrect information from a financial institution. The IRS can waive the excise tax entirely for reasonable cause, but you have to ask and explain what happened and how you fixed it.
  • Don't wait for the IRS to find it. Nothing forces you to self-report a missed RMD, but the statute of limitations on assessing the excise tax generally doesn't start running until you file Form 5329 for that year. Skip the form and the exposure can sit open far longer than two years.

Can the Penalty Be Waived Completely?

Yes, and the IRS grants these waivers more often than most people expect, provided you can show reasonable cause and that you've already taken steps to fix the shortfall. A documented hospitalization, a death in the family, bad instructions from your IRA custodian, or a genuine clerical error are all examples that have supported waiver requests. A full waiver means the excise tax is reduced to zero, not just cut to 10%, but it requires the written explanation on Form 5329 and there's no guarantee the IRS grants it. The practical approach most advisors recommend: take the missed distribution first, then file for the waiver, rather than waiting on an answer before you act.

How Much Could a Missed RMD Actually Cost You?

Run the real numbers on a traditional IRA. Say you're 75 with a $500,000 IRA balance as of December 31 of the prior year. Under the current IRS Uniform Lifetime Table, your distribution factor at 75 is 24.6, which puts your RMD at $500,000 ÷ 24.6, or about $20,325. If you miss the deadline entirely and never correct it, the excise tax is 25% of that shortfall, or roughly $5,081. Catch it and correct it within the two-year window, and the same shortfall costs about $2,033 instead, a real difference of just over $3,000 for acting fast. Miss two consecutive years without correcting either one, and you're compounding two separate excise tax exposures, each calculated on that year's own shortfall, not combined into one bigger number but also not forgiven just because time passed.

That math only covers the penalty. The missed RMD amount itself still gets added to your taxable income once you do withdraw it, on top of whatever excise tax applies, so the real cost of forgetting is the tax plus the penalty, not the penalty alone.

Does the Deadline Ever Move to April 1 Instead?

Only for your very first RMD. If you're taking an RMD for the first time, the deadline for that one specific distribution can be delayed to April 1 of the following year instead of December 31. Every RMD after that first one is due December 31 of its own year, with no April grace period, which means someone who delays their first RMD to the following April ends up taking two RMDs in that same calendar year, one by April 1 and the next by December 31. For the exact age that first RMD kicks in, since SECURE 2.0 changed it and the rules now depend on your birth year, see our breakdown of RMD age 73 vs. 75.

If you inherited the account rather than owning it yourself, the deadline math and the penalty exposure work differently, and the stakes can be just as real. Our guide to the inherited IRA 10-year rule covers what happens when a beneficiary misses an RMD inside that window. And if the goal is avoiding a large RMD altogether rather than fixing a missed one, a QLAC lets you carve out up to $210,000 of your IRA balance and delay RMDs on that portion specifically, which is worth knowing about before your balance gets large enough that a missed deadline becomes an expensive mistake.

None of this is a reason to panic over a distribution you're not sure you took. It's a reason to check your account statements before December 31, confirm your custodian actually processed this year's RMD, and if you find a gap from this year or an earlier one, fix it and file Form 5329 before the correction window closes rather than after.

—
Spicy Investing